mogan legal report tourism tax appeal

Mogán paid €14,999 for legal report backing tourism tax appeal

Compiled with the help of artificial intelligence, based on Spanish-language information. Source below the article.

Mogán pays €14,999 for external report backing tourist tax appeal

The Ayuntamiento de Mogán has paid the Madrid law firm Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo €14,999 through a public company to produce the external legal opinion that the government led by Onalia Bueno (Juntos por Mogán) has presented as legal backing for its appeal to the Supreme Court against the ruling of the High Court of Justice of the Canary Islands (TSJC) that annulled the municipal tourist tax of 15 cents per person per night.

The sum is no coincidence. It sits a single euro below the €15,000 threshold that the Public Sector Contracts Act sets as the ceiling for direct awards of service contracts, without a public tender or negotiated procedure. It is a pattern the southern council has already used on previous occasions with other renowned law firms in Madrid to resolve judicial matters.

Contract channelled through the municipal company Gestiona

The hiring of Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo, whose partners include former judges of the Supreme Court’s Administrative Chamber — the body that must first decide whether to admit the appeal and then whether to uphold it — was carried out through the public company Mogán Gestión Municipal (Gestiona), which handles the council’s revenue collection and tax law advice. The company’s general director is Eduardo Álamo Perera, the lawyer who presented the tourist tax alongside Bueno in December 2024 and the person who has registered various trademarks with the Ministry of the Interior under which the mayor of Mogán intends to stand in the regional and local elections of May 2027.

At the press conference in late 2024, Bueno and Álamo described the levy as a pioneering initiative in local government that would help fund public services. Until it was annulled by the TSJC last summer, the council collected €1.4 million. On the same day the Canarian court’s ruling became known, 14 July, the mayor and the general director of Gestiona appeared again to say that the decision would be appealed to the Supreme Court, that the funds would remain frozen until the ruling was final and that the tax would continue to be charged.

Report justified by “the uniqueness of the contract’s object”

According to documentation seen by Canarias Ahora, six days after that press conference a technician from the legal services of the municipal company Gestiona signed a report justifying the need to contract specialised advice for “the study and issuing of an opinion on the viability of lodging an appeal in cassation” before the Supreme Court. The contracting body cites only “the uniqueness of the object of the contract” as its motivation, without explaining what that uniqueness is. This formula, already used by the council to justify payments to other law firms, allowed the municipal company to award the work directly to the firm chaired by Javier Cremades for €14,999, with a execution period of twenty days and a payment period of 30 days from the award.

As Gestiona states on its website, it is a company whose capital is entirely municipal and which holds the status of contracting authority. It is therefore subject to the same procedures as the council. The opinion is dated in Madrid on 24 September, the day Gestiona says it received it, but bears Cremades’s electronic signature of 26 October, days before the mayor decided to take the matter through the urgent route to the local Governing Board.

Twenty-six pages, with only a dozen on the TSJC ruling

The Madrid firm’s report runs to 26 pages and warns in its conclusions that it is not “formally” a preparatory document for the appeal before the Supreme Court. Of the 23 pages of pure content (the other three are the cover, introduction and index), the firm devotes around ten to explaining the general cassation regime and the requirements for admission. The analysis applied to the TSJC ruling therefore sits in the middle of the document, across a dozen pages.

In its opening section, the opinion summarises the grounds of the Canarian court’s ruling. The TSJC’s Administrative Chamber concluded that Mogán council had tried to disguise as a fee what was in reality a tax, and that it had no powers to do so. It also considered that the taxable event (what is paid for) was defined with “ambiguous, imprecise, generic” expressions such as “actions arising from tourism and the sustainability of the destination”, which made it impossible to know which specific services or activities the levy finances. The ruling referred to Supreme Court case law, which ties a fee to a specific public service and to the benefit of the person paying it.

Firm sees grounds for cassation but urges caution

In the opinion delivered to the municipal public company, Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo argues that three circumstances support the existence of a cassation interest capable of establishing case law: the ruling annuls a general provision, the high court has never ruled on a municipal tourist tax, and the doctrine it sets would affect a growing number of councils. The report argues that a ruling by the Supreme Court’s Third Chamber is not only “advisable” but “necessary”.

The opinion nonetheless calls for caution. It states that, “duly formulated”, the appeal to the Supreme Court “could be admitted” for processing, although it acknowledges that the law grants the high court an “almost discretionary” power of selection and that admission is therefore unlikely. Nor does it assess the costs the council might have to pay if the legal action fails. The TSJC has already imposed up to a maximum of €3,000.

Building on that external opinion, both Gestiona’s legal advice service and the council’s own drafted reports that are even more forceful than the original. The first gives a “positive assessment” of the advisability of preparing the appeal in cassation before the Supreme Court. The second maintains that the conclusions of Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo reveal “solid cassation viability”.

Appeal deadline still suspended

The 30-working-day deadline to appeal the TSJC ruling remains suspended. It will not start running until the Canarian court resolves the clarification of judgment requested by the Federation of Hotel and Tourism Employers (FEHT) of Las Palmas.

The award of the €14,999 contract to Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo consolidates a habitual practice within Bueno’s governing team: turning to major law firms based in Madrid, with renowned jurists among their ranks, to take on matters of high political or judicial impact, always using the route of minor contracts. Mogán council has already awarded a minor contract of €15,000 to the lawyer José Antonio Choclán, a judge on leave from the National Court and the mayor’s counsel in her criminal cases, to try to prevent the administration from having to meet subsidiarily the compensation owed to a street vendor of Senegalese origin who was tortured by two local police officers.

During this term, the council has also paid €17,000 to the Montero Aramburu law firm so that the retired Supreme Court judge Rafael Fernández Valverde could draft two reports relating to two other criminal cases in which Onalia Bueno was being investigated, one of them precisely over the award of minor contracts to two related audiovisual production companies administered by two brothers.

Source

Scroll to Top