guanche trepanation skull surgery study

Guanches ‘may have performed skull surgery’

Compiled with the help of artificial intelligence, based on Spanish-language information. Source below the article.

Guanches may have carried out skull surgery, study suggests

The Guanches may have performed cranial trepanations as an early form of surgery to relieve pressure inside the skull. That is the proposition of an international study involving specialists from the University of La Laguna (ULL), which analyses this prehistoric practice and its possible relationship with the cranial decompression techniques used today.

The study, published in the scientific journal World Neurosurgery, examines evidence from various prehistoric populations around the world as well as lesions identified in human remains from the Canary Islands. The research was carried out by Leandro Castañeyra, from the ULL’s Department of Pharmacology and the Children’s Research Institute (CHOC), and Emilio González, from the Department of Internal Medicine. Specialists from the Historical Heritage Service of the Cabildo de Gran Canaria, the Surgery Service of the Hospital Universitario de Canarias and the Face Lab at Liverpool John Moores University also collaborated on the work.

An ancient surgical practice

Trepanation consists of making a deliberate opening in the skull and is one of the oldest known surgical interventions. Although it has traditionally been linked to the treatment of trauma, certain symptoms or ritual practices, its purpose remains a matter of debate.

Among the remains analysed are two large lesions identified in the skulls of two adult individuals from the Barranco del Agua de Dios site in Tenerife. Both show signs of bone remodelling, which suggests they survived for a prolonged period after suffering the injuries. The researchers propose that these marks could be related to a partial trepanation. However, they warn that there is not enough evidence to confirm that these were interventions carried out for therapeutic purposes. The lesions could also be due to trauma, deliberate procedures of another kind or later modifications.

No conclusive evidence in Gran Canaria

The study also recalls research into violence among the pre-Hispanic population of Gran Canaria, which identified cranial trauma in 696 individuals. Of these, 596 had healed lesions and another 100 had unhealed wounds. However, no conclusive evidence of deliberate trepanations was found in this case either.

Lessons from Cusco

To study the possible medical use of these interventions, the authors also draw on remains from other ancient communities. One of the most relevant cases is found in the Cusco region of Peru, where 109 cranial openings have been documented in 66 individuals. Around 83% of these cases showed signs compatible with survival after the operation. In addition, 26 people had multiple openings in the skull.

This last detail is particularly significant for the researchers. The existence of several trepanations in the same individual could indicate that some people survived a first operation and, some time later, needed a further intervention. The authors compare this pattern with certain present-day conditions, such as chronic subdural haematoma, in which a first operation to reduce pressure can work, although it is sometimes necessary to repeat it if the problem returns.

Surgical knowledge built on observation

On the basis of these observations, the study suggests that some prehistoric communities may have developed surgical knowledge by observing people who had suffered trauma. This does not mean they knew the modern concept of intracranial pressure, but rather that they may have identified that certain injuries worsened and that, in some cases, opening the skull could aid recovery.

The research does not rule out that some trepanations had ritual motivations, but it considers that the repetition of these interventions and the signs of survival support the possibility that they were also surgical treatments. To take this question further, the specialists propose using techniques such as computerised tomography, which would make it possible to distinguish deliberate openings from lesions caused by trauma, disease or post-mortem processes.

Hypothesis, not conclusion

In any case, the researchers stress that the available evidence does not allow them to state that the interventions documented in the Canary Islands were operations intended to relieve intracranial pressure. The hypothesis opens a new avenue for studying the medical knowledge of prehistoric populations and the possible development of surgical practices long before modern medicine.

Source

Scroll to Top