canary islands coastal law draft

Canary Islands coastal law could strip protection from degraded shores

Compiled with the help of artificial intelligence, based on Spanish-language information. Source below the article.

Draft law opens door to removing degraded coastline from public domain

The future coastal law of the Canary Islands would allow the regional government or town halls to ask the State to remove the most degraded stretches of shoreline from the public maritime-terrestrial domain, according to the draft of the regulation that the regional executive, made up of Coalición Canaria (CC) and the Partido Popular (PP), has made public this week. Article 24 is the one that contemplates this possibility. In its first section it states that the rehabilitation and renaturalisation of the coast “may” be carried out through a special plan or, where possible, through a works project. And in the second provision it opens the door to removing the most deteriorated stretches of coastline from the public domain. It sets it out as follows: “When any of these spaces is so human-altered and degraded that the elements that identify the public maritime-terrestrial domain can no longer be recognised, the Government of the Canary Islands and/or the corresponding town hall shall request, with justification, that the General State Administration modify the demarcation and declassify the land, in accordance with state regulations governing the coast.”

Unclear criteria for assessing degradation

The draft bill does not clarify to what extent a piece of land must be transformed to fit that scenario. Nor does it determine who should assess it or by what criteria, nor does it specify whether it matters how the degradation has occurred. The state Coastal Law of 1988 expressly establishes that land that has “lost its natural characteristics as beach, cliff or maritime-terrestrial zone” forms part of the public domain. However, it also contemplates its declassification (or declassification, as the regulations call it), following a report from the town hall and the autonomous community, and, above all, provided that those lands are not necessary for the protection of the coastline. The difference with the state law is that the Canarian draft bill turns declassification into a step that the administrations must promote, by establishing that the regional government and town halls “shall request” that it be processed. In addition, it focuses on the degree of degradation of the land, by requiring that it be “so human-altered and degraded” that the elements typical of the public domain can no longer be recognised. The national regulation, to which the draft refers, makes declassification conditional on the land no longer being necessary for the protection of the coastline.

What happens if the State agrees to the request

The State is not obliged to accept the request submitted from the Canary Islands. If it agrees, the land ceases to form part of the public maritime-terrestrial domain and becomes a public asset, like a plot of land or a public building. From that moment on, the Coastal Law allows it to be transferred free of charge to the town hall or the autonomous community, although only for public use or a public service. The Public Assets Law also supports selling it or keeping it as its own property.

Echoes of the Papagayo Arena case

The article of the Canarian text evokes the argument put forward in 2024 by the developer of the illegal Papagayo Arena hotel to oppose the widening of the coastal protection strip resulting from the updating of the demarcation, which meant that most of the complex came to fall within the protection easement zone, that is, the strip of one hundred metres inland where uses are heavily restricted. At the time it argued that there was no longer “anything to protect” in the place where the establishment is located, near the Los Ajaches Natural Monument. The demarcation went ahead and the Audiencia Nacional refused to suspend it on a precautionary basis. The Canarian draft bill does not refer to the protection easement, but to the public maritime-terrestrial domain. But both approaches share the same logic: that the transformation of the coast can justify a reduction in its protection.

Tourist installations deemed “convenient”

The draft also takes tourist installations in the protection easement to be “convenient” when they are envisaged in an planning instrument. In other words, it would be enough for an urban planning, tourism or coastal plan to include them for them to receive that consideration. This is how article 42 of the draft puts it: “In view of the link between the coastline and tourist activity, works, installations and activities with that purpose and classification shall be considered convenient for the use of the public maritime-terrestrial domain when they are envisaged in planning instruments, whether general, tourism or coastal, in accordance with the provisions of this law.” The question is not trivial, since the state Coastal Law considerably limits the uses permitted in the protection easement. It establishes that only works, installations or activities that, by their nature, cannot be located elsewhere may be authorised, such as marine cultivation or actions providing services “convenient” for the use of the coast. “Convenient” is also the adjective used by the Directorate General of the Government of the Canary Islands to describe the plan of the developer of Cuna del Alma in the protection easement zone of Puertito de Adeje. There it plans a restaurant, an open-air swimming pool and a car park for buggies as part of the development of 420 luxury villas it intends to build in the south of Tenerife. The Public Prosecutor’s Office does not see it that way, considering that these constructions “may have another location outside” the coastal protection strip. And its request for a precautionary halt to the works was the one upheld by the courts around half a year ago, following a criminal complaint filed by various environmental and social groups. The director general of Coasts of the Government of the Canary Islands, Antonio Acosta, appointed by Coalición Canaria, appears as an investigated party in that case.

Other provisions of the draft bill

Other provisions of the draft bill: article 44 states that where there are legal works or installations, the transit easement (the walkway beside the shore that must remain free so that anyone can walk along the coast) shall be “at least three metres”, half the state regulation’s six. The fifth additional provision establishes that rural settlements meeting a series of requirements “shall be considered urban land”. For its part, the fourth transitional provision takes as given that walkways, streets, squares and other installations located on public domain land or subject to an easement before 1988 have a qualifying title. The draft bill will also enable the creation of a register of traditional coastal settlements to “promote, where appropriate, their legalisation”.

An insular law for the archipelago’s coastline

The future coastal law of the Canary Islands aims at “the protection, planning and use of the Archipelago’s coastline, as well as the planning and management of maritime space”. The regional government justifies drawing up its own regulation on the grounds of the islands’ “numerous singularities” and the need to achieve a “balance”. The regional executive says it seeks to adapt the national law to the island reality, simplicity and legal certainty, understood as “specifying and clarifying” indeterminate concepts.

Source

Scroll to Top